ValerieW-16 on "The Oxymoron Called the SAT Literature Subject Test"

by ValerieW-16, 30 July 2009


I’ve never been a fan of standardized testing, but my recent ordeal regarding taking the SAT Literature Subject Test last weekend confirmed all my fears.

Pardon me for sounding a little cocky, but English has always been one of my strengths and passions both inside and outside of school. Which is probably why doing so poorly on the test was such an unpleasant surprise.

No, I haven’t received my scores yet, but then again, solid proof isn’t necessary to know certain things. My bias is probably speaking for itself here, but I honestly believe the subjectivity of literary analysis is such that a multiple choice-based standardized test such as the SAT Literature Subject Test is completely inappropriate as a means of assessment.

I’m tempted to quote a question word for word in order to better illustrate my point, but the College Board would probably come after my butt with a whip in hand. And so I will content myself with making the argument that the beauty of language lies in its wonderful ambiguity: two people can find completely different meanings in the same word, let alone an entire text. But this beauty sure fades when the appeal of selecting the “right” answer counts for marks that, for some reason, play a disproportionately large role in determining one’s future.

Being a writer and all, I’m obviously a fan of language as a Way of Knowing (my TOK teacher would be so proud if he was reading this). I love the English language, in all its mysterious connotations that require secret passwords to decode, and the shadowy ambiguity that keeps everyone guessing. Sometimes, however, it is this same ambiguity that is so incredibly frustrating. Sometimes, we need a sense of direction. Sometimes, we all need a little clarity.


Bookmark with:

Delicious      Digg      reddit      Facebook      StumbleUpon     
Please join our facebook group     
Previous | Next
more recent blogs
CORNY OR NOT? ... Cast your votes for these love Song classics ... PART 5/6
CORNY OR NOT? ... Cast your votes for these love Song classics ... PART 4/6
CORNY OR NOT? ... Cast your votes for these love Song classics ... PART 3/6
CORNY OR NOT? ... Cast your votes for these love Song classics ... PART 2/6
CORNY OR NOT? ... Cast your votes for these love Song classics from the olden days ... :D Part 1/6
MOVIE FRIDAYS: Highlining and Basejumping ... True Freedom is the ability to make your dreams come true
Body
more ...
iCUBED.us is a webazine for, by, and about youth aged to 25.

As a regular columnist for iCUBED.us writing around a particular topic, your opinions will be read by students around the world and you end our year-long Blogger's Internship with a writing portfolio as excellent as you make it. We provide the space and some general guidelines, you provide the words.

You have to be invited to join our forums- so if you're aged below 25 be on the lookout for your invitation and for opportunities to introduce yourself to us - the folks who run www.iCUBED.us ... Check in regularly for a chance to compete in one of our "open-to-the-NONmembers' contests"... You might surprise yourself and take first prize.

NOTA BENE:
Any work you submit will not be returned, so please keep a copy. If you mail us a self addressed envelope we will acknowledge receipt by return post.

COPYRIGHT STATEMENT:
All copyrights are assigned to iCUBED.us once works are submitted to us. We retain non-exclusive rights to publish all such work in any format. All content on the website becomes the property of iCUBED.us, however, all contributors retain the right to republish their works elsewhere, with written notice to iCUBED.us.